User-Centered Design of Medical Devices

August 18, 2020


Satu Peltonen

Beijing sky scraper & cctv tower

User-centered design of medical devices positions the user and human factors in the heart of the design process to enhance the usability, safety and effectiveness of the medical device, where usability testing is a critical component of the human factors engineering process.

Introducing Human Factors, Usability and Design Thinking

In recent years medical technology has taken a trend towards creating personalized care while seeking ways to enhance quality for patients and to lower healthcare costs. At the same time developers have to keep in mind the ease of use of the devices and gaining regulatory approval for them in the highly internationalized market.

Capturing user profiles and use environments across nations and cultures needs more creative, wide-reaching, and complex problem-solving approaches than conventional preference of scientific and technological advancement.

Even so, it is not uncommon to observe medical technology developers to concentrate rather on engineering than on user needs and usability, although human factors have been identified as particularly important aspect of the risk management plan for medical device safety.

 So why to put user in the center of medical technology development?

Leaving the fact aside that usability requirements have been addressed by FDA and MDR in regulatory requirements and guidelines to enhance device performance and safety, the most profound reason is to protect people from injury and death due to use errors as they arise from a poorly realized fit between the user and device. One sadly famous example is the programming of infusion pumps, where a simple decimal error of 50 instead of 5.0 – example-wise – could lead to a fatal drug dose delivery. This error has been so frequent that the industry has coined the expression “death-by-decimal point” to initiate use correction processes to address this particular medical error.

To highlight how broad this issue is, it is estimated that thousands of people die due to errors involving medical devices each year. By reviewing FDA’s MAUDE (Manufacturer and User Facility Device Experience) and MDR (Medical Device Reporting) databases it can be seen that several hundred thousand medical devices are being reported on a yearly basis.

To put it simply: From a manufacturers point of view a medical device can be optimized toward safety as long as it remains within the domain of engineering, but once the device has entered the market its safety is dependent on the user. User types and environments of use range widely and even among medical professionals’ differences of sophistication cause a great deal of variety in the user experience, not to mention differences between nations and cultures.

While market for medical technology is getting more and more international it is not enough to consider questions like “who will use this device?” or “what are the expectations of each user group?”, instead questions like “what are the color and symbol code comprehensions?” come into the picture while considering if the design should be universal and free of any special cultural specifics or specially designed for one specific culture.

Such issues and considerations bring a whole new challenge to defining user profiles and use environments, but also emphasizes the need for more user-centered design process. Entering design thinking, which is a human-centered iterative approach for creative and critical problem solving that works well hand in hand with human factors research investigating human characteristics and use environment to translate this into medical device usability and to integrate this into the whole medical device life cycle.

The advantages of design thinking tools are the use of diverse and multidisciplinary teams that tackle to re-define unknown or ill-defined problems by focusing what is most important for the user and their interactions in their real-life environment. The aim is to break the naturally developed patterns of thinking to produce unconventional and original ideas and to bring diverse voices and user-driven criteria into the design process.

As designing for another culture is less intuitive and designers are easily swayed by assumptive thinking in the process it is even more important to seek understanding of the user journey where designers need to break out of their cultural bubbles. It is not about designing for certain languages or traditions, but for different cultural dimension, color and symbol psychology but also for different mental models.

Healing Childhood Abuse Wounds

Childhood abuse and assault can have a significant impact on a person’s mental wellbeing in adulthood. The trauma experienced in childhood can have lasting effects that can manifest in a variety of ways, including anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

Breaking the Taboo

A worrying trend observed across all regions and language groups is the global decline in the mental wellbeing of younger generations. The Mental Health Million data show that with each successively younger generation, there is a decline in mental wellbeing, as reflected in falling MHQ scores and a corresponding increase in the proportion of people who are distressed or struggling with significant mental health problems.

Innovation for Mental Wellness

Even today, mental health issues are branded with a high level of stigma although it has a profound impact on the individual and society as a whole. Negative perceptions that stigmatize mental health issues may discourage and prevent individuals to seek help. This combined with poor access to mental health care services leads to significant public health issues, not to forget the economic costs to society, including healthcare costs, lost productivity, and reduced economic growth. To begin with, mental health is a public health issue affecting a person’s overall well-being, quality of life, and productivity and is of vital importance to both individuals and societies.

The Entrepreneurial Boost Program

The Entrepreneurial Boost program – or Yrittäjyysbuusti in Finnish – is a program co-funded by the Pirkanmaa region Centre for Economic Development, Transport and the Environment, TE Services, and the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment of Finland. The program is a unique service model to support the entrepreneurial aspirations of early-stage entrepreneurs who are at the beginning of an entrepreneurial venture or business journey.

New Partnership Goals: inXso and BrainStormCorner

inXso is glad to share our new partnership goals with BrainStormCorner, founded as a business think tank with global roots, born right next to Tampere University campus. BrainStormCorner is a versatile toolbox of business services and research commercialization, based on long international and multidisciplinary experience.

Life Science & Medical Technology EXPO’s in Asia 2022 – Where you should start

Expos, trade fairs, and shows are a way to build business networks and search for partners that open new potential markets. It brings a lot of positive exposure for companies and their innovations, builds customer interest, and opens doors for collaborative projects along the life science and medical technology value chain.

Horizon Europe Cluster Health – Research and Innovation Funding

The EU Research and Innovation Programme 2021-2027 has gathered a lot of attention from the research communities around Europe this time around with their Cluster Health topics that are open for proposals. The published destinations aim to address acute and long-term problems in the healthcare ecosystem and the health and well-being of citizens from a societal point of view – without forgetting the lessons learned from the Covid-19 pandemic.

inXso 2021 MedTech Series R&D focal points

For 2021 inXso has created a webinar series outlining some specific features that are essential for global design of medical technology, and introduces some regulatory aspects in context of EU MDR and Swiss regulatory landscape, as well as some basic features from Chinese and Japanese regulations that everyone – or every company – considering these healthcare markets should now of.

How to build internationalization strategy for HealthTech

It is a known fact that most internationalization attempts fail due to lack of thorough preparation and adhering to the chosen strategy.

When it comes to life sciences – healthcare technology, biomedical technology and pharmaceuticals – that is an industry operating in a heavily regulated environment, any attempt to seek market growth through internationalization faces a multitude of specific considerations.

User-Centered Design of Medical Devices

In recent years medical technology has taken a trend towards creating personalized care while seeking ways to enhance quality for patients and to lower healthcare costs. At the same time developers have to keep in mind the ease of use of the devices and gaining regulatory approval for them in the highly internationalized market.

The Internationalization Challenge of Biomedical Innovations

The life science industry distinguishes itself from other high-technology industries with such fundamental dimensions as applying scientific knowledge to provide technological solutions aiming to improve health care and quality of life – in a highly regulated environment. At the same time, usually purchasing decisions are not made by end-consumers, but their physicians or such third party as an insurance company, for example.

Apply for HealthTech Online Pitching

On 22nd May an online pitching for HealthTech Startups is organized by inXso together with Slush China to Venture Capital investors of which there is a significant participation from the Chinese Venture Capital investment companies focused on HealthTech, BioPharma and BioMedTech.